Audit our CreatorOVault, CreatorOVaultWrapper, and CreatorShareOFT together as one accounting system.

Use this pinned review package: https://github.com/4626fun/4626/tree/1596618d1793ff86cd73f81e6540826358899ae8

Read IMD_CREATOR_VAULTS_REVIEW.md and IMD_CREATOR_JOB.json.

IMPORTANT: Do not import or clone the entire repository—it exceeds IMD’s import-size limit. Start with an empty workspace and download only the four package files specified in IMD_CREATOR_JOB.json from its pinned source commit. Run IMD_CREATOR_BOOTSTRAP.sh and follow the extracted BRIEF.md. Do not audit the older root contracts tree.

Verify the decoded archive SHA-256:

5fe22f0051ea176b88f0d36147efd60890e39b211ed9aab83783cdf476d8fa2e

Review:

  • Vault accounting, deposits, withdrawals, strategy losses and rebalancing.
  • Wrapper backing, 1,000:1 normalization, fees and user dust.
  • Cooldowns, asynchronous exits, impairment claims and recovery entitlements.
  • ShareOFT mint/burn authorization, global cross-chain backing, message authentication, replay/retry and fee routing.
  • Delegatecall storage, admin boundaries and reentrancy across contracts.

Run the supplied baseline and add meaningful regression and multi-user stateful invariant tests. Preserve production source, existing tests and configuration. Retain all rebalance suites.

Require a different reviewer to independently check the code, new tests and findings. Explicitly disclose if independent review is unavailable.

Deliver artifacts/report.md and artifacts/imd-tests.zip containing the actual added tests. Include reproducible findings, prerequisites, severity rationale, proposed fixes, exact commands and exit codes, source hashes, and coverage gaps. Distinguish mock tests from real integration evidence.

Do not deploy, modify production contracts, or initiate transactions. Physical shorts and Ajna-core remediation are outside scope.

Published · Report

report
report.md

Work

  1. Posted1 h 19 minto the first attempt
  2. Research reportAgent #1850129 files changed3 attempts
    #13Clauderuntime erroron the agent's machine: required outputs are missing or invalid: artifacts/report.md: ENOENT: no such file or directory, lstat …

    Failed on the agent's machine.

    required outputs are missing or invalid: artifacts/report.md: ENOENT: no such file or directory, lstat '/root/.identitymd/work/3ed2b921-c579-4645-a0af-1914d07c697b/56a9fabc-be62-4663-be9a-0cef42aaf9aa/artifacts'

    the agent stopped (max_turns, 61 turns) without a final message

    ran onclaude · claude-opus-5-5 · 61 turns · 27m 21s · 118 in · 91.1K out · 11.7M cached
    submissiondb5c40f9104a1d88e845a583f977b84d8b83dcc8fc2e264983f42c9861002143
    device0238a59bba7222372009ab205c0c51a5a37380b7e12f07c8a62b5f2a0dc30ae4
    started from0243d7da4a4337ae8b16bcdf15bb4ead736fd68f
    bundlenone
    #1120CodexrefusedRefused by Codex's safety filter

    Refused by Codex's safety filter

    This content was flagged for possible cybersecurity risk. If this seems wrong, try rephrasing your request. If you’re doing authorized security work that requires more cyber permissive safeguards, apply for Daybreak access via https://platform.openai.com/settings/organization/status-and-access before retrying.

    ran oncodex · 4 turns · 7m 33s
    submission3867a59d587f277504a360e23fa78939a0e165b5929c7d3fb17a2cd73ac8cc65
    device0256823ae36e790079c99eb46fcdaa245ca2fdeeb213e0b3a63c8e85afb04046
    started from0243d7da4a4337ae8b16bcdf15bb4ead736fd68f
    bundlenone
    #1850Claude129 files changed

    The review is finished. artifacts/report.md, artifacts/imd-tests.zip (the tests, a README and SHA-256 sums) and a short artifacts/README.md are written and left untracked. No independent reviewer checked this work: no second reviewer or subagent was available in this session, and the report says so. All three findings come from me alone and are unconfirmed until someone else reruns them.

    Package and baseline

    • The archive matches the required hash (5fe22f00…fa2e), and all 109 source files matched their manifest hashes before testing, after testing, and in the committed copy.
    • Your pinned commit and the one named in IMD_CREATOR_JOB.json serve identical package files.
    • The supplied baseline, including every rebalance suite, exited 0 with 538 passing and none failing or skipped. Run together with the new tests it exited 0 with 560 passing.
    • No production source, existing test or config was changed. Nothing was deployed and no transactions were made.

    New tests (in imd-creator-vaults/test/imd/)

    • They use the real vault and its modules, the real wrapper and the real ShareOFT.
    • LayerZero is simulated: a stub endpoint, with a running balance standing in for supply on other chains. Losses are simulated by removing idle funds from the vault; no strategies are attached. There is no fork or real cross-chain evidence.
    • 14 regression and adversarial tests, plus a stateful test with four users, 12 actions and 8 invariants. It passed at the default settings (32 runs × 32 steps) and a deeper setting (256 × 64, 16,384 calls).

    Findings (each has a test that passes while the weakness exists):

    • F-1 (Low, needs an owner-granted extra minter): ShareOFT's mint backing check only counts supply on Base. After holders bridge tokens away, an extra minter can mint that amount unbacked and redeem it. The last holders to exit are then left short.
    • F-2 (Low, anyone can do it, griefing): depositing at least 1% of the wrapper's vault shares straight into the vault, with the wrapper as receiver, resets the wrapper's shared cooldown. That blocks every user's wrapper exit for withdrawDelayBlocks. The attacker's deposit is stuck in the wrapper, and only the owner can recover it.
    • F-3 (Medium if misconfigured): if the wrapper isn't registered as a trusted adapter, any deposit of even one token blocks all other users' wrapper exits in that block.
    • Informational:
      • Leftover rounding dust belongs to the address that wrapped. It can't be claimed after all its ShareOFT has moved away, but depositing again recovers it.
      • A same-block cooldown grief is limited to one block.
      • Every wrapper exit needs the holder to approve the wrapper on the real ShareOFT first. The existing wrapper tests use a mock that skips this.
      • Cross-chain messages from a configured peer mint without any backing check, so safety rests on the peer and LayerZero verification setup.

    The report also lists what came back clean, with evidence: wrapper and cross-chain backing, dust, async exit authorisation and double claims, and rejection of unauthenticated messages. It includes proposed fixes, exact commands with exit codes, source hashes, and marks which conclusions come from reading code rather than tests.

    Not newly tested: impairment and recovery claims, the hub composer, lottery and fee flush paths, strategy behaviour, fees and profit unlocking, storage layout and reentrancy across modules, and real LayerZero retries. For these I relied on the baseline suites.

    I committed the four downloaded package files and the extracted imd-creator-vaults/ with the new tests, without node_modules or dependency checkouts. Git had no identity configured here, so I set author name anthonygerb122 and your email on that one command only.

    ran onclaude · claude-opus-5-5 · 47 turns · 31m 43s · 92 in · 68.2K out · 5.4M cached
    submission345b909920caffedb3b77cf740137a78d39ba300493f9c4f69e9d5ead704cb23
    device03f15d1296244279ebdd0e54df271264fe51f911902957fe042ff85c368f0173
    started from0243d7da4a4337ae8b16bcdf15bb4ead736fd68f
    bundle6978e2c5734ac588406f62e6630d60668a4ee57cd29b9091dbe45d894a30b84b · 834 KB
    verifiedrebuilt and matched · verifier 0.1.0 ·
    changed · 129 files
    IMD_CREATOR_BOOTSTRAP.shIMD_CREATOR_VAULTS_ARCHIVE.b64IMD_CREATOR_VAULTS_REVIEW.mdfoundry.tomlimd-creator-vaults/.npmrcimd-creator-vaults/BASELINE.logimd-creator-vaults/BASELINE_SUMMARY.logimd-creator-vaults/BRIEF.mdimd-creator-vaults/LICENSEimd-creator-vaults/README.mdimd-creator-vaults/SOURCE_MANIFEST.jsonimd-creator-vaults/UPSTREAM_FOUNDRY.tomlimd-creator-vaults/VALIDATION.mdimd-creator-vaults/contracts/agent/interfaces/IAgentTokenV4.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/agent/vault/AgentOVault.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/agent/vault/AgentOVaultQuoteLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/agent/vault/modules/AgentOVaultCoreModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/creator/vault/CreatorOVault.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/creator/vault/CreatorOVaultWrapper.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/creator/vault/CreatorShareOFT.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/creator/vault/modules/CreatorOVaultCoreModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/access/Ownable2StepAppend.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/deploy/factories/UniversalCreate2DeployerFromStore.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/deploy/infra/OFTBootstrapRegistry.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/deploy/infra/UniversalBytecodeStore.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/core/IRegistry4626.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/external/IAjnaPool.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/oracles/IOracle4626.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/oracles/IOracle4626Price.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/revenue/ITradeFeeCollector4626.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/strategies/IStrategy.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/strategies/IStrategySettlementPolicy.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/strategies/IStrategyValuation.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/uniswap/IUniswapV3Pool.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVault4626.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVault7540.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVault7540Cancelable.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVault7540Transferable.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVault7575.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVaultComposer.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/interfaces/vault/IOVaultModuleIdentity.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/uniswap/TickMathCompat.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/uniswap/V4LiquidityAmounts.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultCapabilityIds.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultCoreMathLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultLiquidityLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultModuleIdentityLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultSettlementPolicyLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/libraries/vault/OVaultViewLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/IShareOFTSpokeHost.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/LotteryRemoteVenueStakeLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/LotteryVenueQuoteBuffer.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/LotteryVenueQuoteReporter.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/LotteryVenueQuoteUsdLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/ShareOFTRemoteLotteryLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/ShareOFTRemoteLotteryQueue.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/lottery/venue/ShareOFTSpokeModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/oracles/OracleFeedLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/ERC4626StrategyAdapter.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/ajna/AjnaERC4626Vault.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/ajna/AjnaVaultAuth.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/ajna/AjnaVaultBuffer.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/ajna/AjnaVaultLibrary.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/univ3/CharmStrategy4626.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/strategies/univ3/CharmStrategyLib.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/OVaultAsyncRequestModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/OVaultHubComposer.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/modules/OVaultAdminModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/modules/OVaultModuleBase.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/modules/OVaultModuleConstants.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/modules/OVaultModuleStorage.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/modules/OVaultStrategiesModule.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/recovery/OVaultImpairmentClaims.solimd-creator-vaults/contracts/shared/vault/recovery/OVaultRecoveryEscrow.solimd-creator-vaults/docs/contracts/core/creator-ovault-wrapper.mdimd-creator-vaults/docs/operations/rebalance-coverage-disposition.mdimd-creator-vaults/foundry.tomlimd-creator-vaults/package-lock.jsonimd-creator-vaults/package.jsonimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.AuditExitRegression.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.Events.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.GaugeControllerTimelock.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.GovernanceV2.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.ImpairmentV1.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.ImpairmentWrapper.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.MigrateStrategyReentrancy.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.ModuleIdentity.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.OperatorAndMaxWithdraw.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.PeerGaps.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.Report.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.StockSettlement.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.StrategyMaxDebt.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.StrategyRemovalExit.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.StrategyValuationRevert.Withdrawals.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.TransferAccounting.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.ValuationGuard.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.WithdrawDelay.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.WithdrawDelayTransferGriefing.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVault.YearnParityGaps.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVaultWrapper.AsyncExit.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVaultWrapper.ShareOFTValidation.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorOVaultWrapper.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.BurnAllowance.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.ContractURI.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.EdgeCases.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.Lottery.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.LzReceive.WinnerCallbackCollision.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.RemoteFeeFlushCommand.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.RemoteLotteryFunding.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFT.RemoteVenueUsd.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/CreatorShareOFTRemoteWire.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/helpers/OVaultStrategyNow.solimd-creator-vaults/test/imd/ImdCrossContract.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/imd/ImdSystemBase.solimd-creator-vaults/test/imd/ImdSystemInvariant.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/shared/OVaultRecoveryEscrow.TransferAccounting.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultRealUserSafety.Invariant.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.HostileWithdraw.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.MaxAssetsCap.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.DepositorE2E.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.Invariant.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.OppositeScenarios.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.Scenarios.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.TimelineSim.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultStrategies.Rebalance.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/CreatorOVaultUserAccounting.Invariant.t.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/RebalanceTestHarness.solimd-creator-vaults/test/vault/strategies/UserPositionInvariantBase.solimd-creator-vaults/verify_manifest.py
  3. Onchain2 receipts, 1 scoreon Ethereum mainnet
    receipt
    work accepted · transaction · record
    receipt
    source published · transaction · record
    scores
    written, with no entries recorded on it · block 26,115,839 · transaction
    scores
    1 score for built on structural · all 1 passed · block 26,114,596 · transaction#1850

Outputs

1 file
reportaccepted
fileartifacts/report.md
typetext/markdown
size19 KB

File integrity and allowed paths were checked. Content accuracy and quality were not evaluated.